Car Key Replacement vs Duplication: What’s Best for You?
If your car key still works but you want a backup, or it’s lost entirely and you need a new one from scratch, you’re looking at two different jobs – duplication and replacement. They sound similar but involve different tools, time and cost. Here’s how to tell which one you need.
Car key duplication – when you still have a working key
Duplication means cutting and programming a second key using your existing one as the master. It’s the faster, cheaper option, and it’s the one we always recommend before you’re down to your last key – not after. Most duplicates for modern cars include a transponder chip and remote, both of which we program on-site.
Car key replacement – when all keys are lost
Replacement is what’s needed when there’s no working key left to copy from – lost, stolen, or the last one just broke. We cut a new key to match your vehicle’s ignition and program it directly to the car’s immobiliser system from scratch, along with proof of ownership. It takes longer than a duplicate and typically costs more, since there’s no existing key to work from.
Which one should you get?
- Still have one working key? Get a spare cut now – duplication is quick and affordable, and it means you’re never one lost key away from an emergency.
- No working key left? You’ll need a full replacement with programming – call us and we’ll talk you through what’s needed for your specific make and model.
Frequently asked questions
Can I get a duplicate key without visiting a dealership?
Yes. We cut and program duplicate keys on-site for most makes and models, usually faster and cheaper than a dealership, without an appointment.
Do I need the original key to get a replacement?
No – if all keys are lost, we can still cut and program a new one from scratch, provided you can show proof of ownership.
See our car locksmith services for pricing on your specific make, or contact us to get started.